Back to blog

How to Choose an Advertising Agency: A Practical Scorecard

Shusaku Yosa

3つの提案を虫眼鏡とチェックで比較する代理店選定のイラスト / Comparing three agency proposals with a magnifying glass and a checkmark

Choose an advertising agency by aligning the work you need and your definition of success, then comparing experience, the delivery team, improvement methods, fees, and data management. Choosing on reputation or fee rate alone can leave you discovering after signing that essential work is excluded or that the campaign manager has not been identified.

This guide provides a common briefing format and an evaluation scorecard. Copy the tables and adapt them to your assignment. Weights and scoring rules are illustrative examples, not an industry-wide selection standard.

Define the assignment and what success means

Before searching for an agency, write down what you want to change. If the goal is more inquiries, identify the products and customers you want, how duplicates will be handled, and what is outside the sales team’s scope. A goal based only on platform conversions may differ from the result your business needs.

Give candidates the same brief and record additional questions and answers so they can be compared. Do not turn an agency’s proposal assumptions directly into internal targets: first check the assumptions and their evidence.

Information to provide

What to align

Business and customers

Products, target customers, sales regions, competitors, and the path to a sale

Assignment

Which parts of channel selection, management, production, landing page improvement, and measurement are included

Budget

Media spend separately from the total including management, production, and tools

Success definition

What counts as a conversion, qualified inquiry, opportunity, or purchase, and where it is measured

Starting point and constraints

Historical results, available assets, internal approvals, and desired start

Internal team

Main contact and the people who approve products, creative, and budget changes

Look for evidence from comparable conditions

A case study that “halved CPA” may involve a different product, period, budget, or measurement setup. Check more than the industry label: consider customer value, sales cycle, geography, channels, and which part of the process changed.

Even when exact results cannot be disclosed, ask which hypothesis the agency tested, what it changed, and how it chose the next step. Alongside successful examples, ask what it did when results fell short. Those answers help you understand how you would work together.

Understand the sales and delivery team

The person presenting the proposal may not manage the account day to day. Identify the campaign manager, reviewer, absence cover, and any subcontractors. In addition to response speed, confirm who answers which questions and what approval is needed for budget or creative changes.

Compare what a review meeting will decide, not just how often meetings take place. Ask to see an example report that connects previous actions, results, the next hypothesis, required assets, and client approval deadlines.

An agency comparison scorecard

Copy this table for each candidate and retain the answers and supporting documents. One possible scale is 0–4: 0 = fails the requirement, 1 = significant gaps, 2 = meets the minimum, 3 = fits your needs, and 4 = fits your needs with specific supporting evidence. Leave unverified items unscored rather than ranking candidates before the information is available.

Criterion

Example weight

Evidence to request

Score 0–4 / notes

Understanding of goals and scope

20

Clear problem and outcome definitions; excluded work

Not yet verified

Relevant experience

15

Cases with comparable audience, dates, budget, and result definitions

Not yet verified

Actual delivery team

15

Named manager, reviewer, cover, and subcontracting arrangements

Not yet verified

Improvement process and reporting

15

An example connecting hypotheses, changes, results, and next decisions

Not yet verified

Data, measurement, and access

15

Measurement plan, visibility, and a handover inventory

Not yet verified

Contract and operating terms

10

Renewal, termination, change requests, and handover conditions

Not yet verified

Pricing transparency

10

Fee calculation base, minimums, and additional charges

Not yet verified

Calculate weighted points as “weight × score ÷ 4.” A score of 3 on a criterion weighted at 20 contributes 15 points. A score of 4 on every criterion gives 100 points. Change the weights to reflect what matters for your assignment.

Keep mandatory requirements separate from the score. An agency that cannot support a required channel, stay within the necessary budget limit, or clarify data handling at termination has an unresolved condition, even if its overall score is high. For close scores, revisit the evidence and unverified items.

Additional checks for a paid search agency

For search advertising, ask about measurement, search term review, landing pages, and bidding or budget changes as well as keywords. When automated bidding is used, understand which conversion it is being trained toward and when a person will review the decision.

  • How will form submissions, qualified inquiries, and sales be distinguished?
  • How will branded and non-branded searches, or other different conditions, be reported separately?
  • How will irrelevant searches and new messages be reviewed?
  • Who changes ads and landing pages, and which work costs extra?
  • Can media spend, management fees, and production be reviewed separately?

Credentials such as Google Partner status are one input. Consult Google’s advertiser guide to working with third parties and examine the proposed team and assignment rather than relying on a badge alone. Be cautious of statements that misrepresent how advertising works, such as guaranteeing a top ad position at all times.

Questions to ask before signing

Question

What it helps you verify

Which tasks are excluded from this proposal?

Extra costs and gaps in responsibilities

Who will manage and review the account?

The actual delivery and backup team

What will you review, and when, if results miss the target?

The testing process and decision responsibilities

What is the calculation base for media costs and fees?

A consistent basis for cost comparison

Who manages accounts, creative, and measurement?

What your company can access and review

What is handed over if the contract ends?

The scope of data, settings, assets, costs, and work

For detailed pricing calculations, see agency fees and how to read quotes. For the broader role, see what an advertising agency does. If you are replacing an existing partner, also review the agency switching and handover checklist during selection.

Record why you chose the agency and what you will review

Keep more than the total score: record the deciding factors, unresolved questions, each party’s responsibilities, and the first items to review. After signing, check that the promised deliverables and reporting are provided and that measurement definitions remain aligned. Use the same criteria for the review.

Start by completing the scorecard for one candidate. That reveals which information you need and which answers are still missing. To explore ways to organize the brief, responsibilities, budget, and review items internally, see Xtrategy’s features.

Back to blog